About us

Black and white photo of two men on horseback in front of a large building, with a smaller figure standing between them and a lamp post nearby.

Mule Barn Tavern Revives Sandy Hook History

Historic Mule Barn Transformed into Charming Tavern: Welcome to Mule Barn Tavern at Sandy Hook Nestled at the scenic tip of Sandy Hook in Highlands, New Jersey, a landmark restoration project has breathed new life into the historic Mule Barn, transforming it into a magnificent American-style tavern. Mule Barn Tavern not only offers a delightful dining experience but also pays homage to the area's rich history and the significance of restoring this extraordinary location.

Mule Barn Tavern is a love letter to Sandy Hook’s storied past—once a mule barn supporting Fort Hancock, now a cozy, welcoming tavern serving locals and explorers alike. With reclaimed wood, warm lighting, and panoramic coastal views, every visit is a chance to savor delicious food in a space that honors the legacy of this iconic structure.

Blurred image of a dimly lit bar or nightclub with red and orange lights, and silhouettes of people in the background.
Wooden hotel reception desk with
A bartender's hand, wearing a black glove, pours a yellow cocktail through a strainer into a martini glass with a salted rim, on a wooden bar counter.
A hand holding a glass of beer being filled from a tap at a bar. The tap handles are made of wood and metal, with a red and black label showing 'BRICK NJ.' The background shows bottles of alcohol and festive green decorations.

At Mule Barn Tavern, there's something on the menu for everyone. From elevated tavern classics like juicy burgers, fresh seafood, and handcrafted flatbreads to vegetarian-friendly options and hearty seasonal specials, our kitchen delivers bold flavors and satisfying bites for every palate. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch, weekend brunch, or dinner with friends, our diverse menu is designed to hit the spot—no matter what you’re craving!

Complementing the food is a full cocktail menu and an impressive lineup of beers on tap, many sourced from some of the best local breweries across New Jersey. From crisp IPAs and smooth lagers to seasonal small-batch brews, we proudly showcase the flavors of the Garden State in every pour. Whether you’re a craft beer lover or just looking to enjoy a refreshing drink with your meal, our bar has something that pairs perfectly with the Mule Barn experience.

Book a reservation • Book a reservation

Bar counter with beer tap handles, beer branding signs, and a pint of dark beer, whiskey shot glass, and glass of liquor.