MULE BARN TAVERN

Restaurant & Bar in Highlands, NJ

Dine, drink, and unwind at the historic Mule Barn Tavern, the go-to Restaurant & Bar in Sandy Hook, NJ, where hearty American fare meets rich local history on the shores of Sandy Hook. Whether you're craving comfort food or cocktails, this Restaurant & Bar in Highlands, NJ offers good vibes, great views, and unforgettable meals!

A neon sign spelling 'BOURBON' hangs above a shelf with various bourbon bottles, decorated with green shamrock garland, set against a brick wall background.

• Historic dining Experience •

Mule Barn Tavern has been thoughtfully restored into a lively Restaurant & Bar in Highlands, NJ, bringing together food, drinks, and live music. Located at the scenic tip of Sandy Hook, this welcoming Restaurant & Bar in Sandy Hook, NJ combines rustic charm, warm hospitality, and stunning coastal views. Whether you're stopping by for brunch, a cocktail, or a weekend show, there’s always something to savor.

Baked stuffed jalapeño peppers topped with cheese, cilantro, and drizzled with green sauce on a black skillet.
Person holding a lobster roll sandwich with a glass of iced tea nearby, and a plate of pasta with vegetables and a piece of bread on a wooden table.
Close-up of a fork picking up a bite of fresh salad containing greens, sliced oranges, strawberries, feta cheese, nuts, and dressing, with a white plate and wooden table in the background.
Soft pretzels with mustard and cheese dips on a checkered paper-lined metal tray, with a beer in a glass nearby, on a wooden table.
 

Book a reservation

*Reservation are NOT required for parties smaller than 8. For parties of 8 or more, reservations are recommended.

Private parties:

A bar with various beer tap handles and beer logos, including Guinness, Carlsberg, Heineken, Harp, and Budweiser, in a cozy pub setting.

 • FAQs •

  • Smaller groups are welcome to walk in. Reservations are only required for parties of 8 or more— especially on weekends and during events.

  • Absolutely! We’re happy to welcome walk-ins any time we have available seating.

  • Yes! Our outdoor patio is open during the warmer months and offers great views and a relaxed vibe.

  • Yes! Well-behaved dogs are welcome in our outdoor seating area. Bring your pup and enjoy the day with us!

A wooden reception desk in a restaurant with a sign that reads 'HULSE BEACH BAR' on the front.

• ABOUT US •

Historic Mule Barn Transformed into Charming Tavern: Welcome to Mule Barn Tavern at Sandy Hook
Nestled at the scenic tip of Sandy Hook in Highlands, New Jersey, this iconic Restaurant & Bar in Highlands, NJ has been reimagined into a magnificent American-style tavern.

Mule Barn Tavern not only offers a delightful dining experience but also celebrates the area’s heritage, making it a must-visit Restaurant & Bar in Sandy Hook, NJ. Once a mule barn supporting Fort Hancock, it now welcomes locals and visitors with cozy ambiance, reclaimed wood, warm lighting, and panoramic coastal views. Every visit is a chance to savor delicious food while honoring the legacy of this extraordinary structure.

 

• NEXT EVENTS •

Mule Barn NEWSLETTER

Sign up to receive special offers and stay in the loop on our upcoming events.

• What our customers say •

←
  • “A great place to grab lunch after enjoying the beautiful Sandy Hook. The historic building really was a mule barn. They have fun local craft beers and a good selection of salads, burgers, pizza and more. Also a brunch menu on weekend. Good vegetarian options. Friendly, efficient service and reasonable prices.” Nancy L
    img
  • “Stumbled upon a great place on Sandy Hook. First time all the way out to the end and found this gem. Cool place. Nice staff. Delicious and fresh food. Indoor and outdoor dining. Served quick and clean restrooms. Definitely will be back.” PJ K
    img
  • “While there was a 30 minute wait, I decided to sit at the bar and order my food there. They have a small bar outside and a much larger one inside which is where I decided to stay. I had the pork belly sliders and they were amazing. You have to try them.” Robinson Soto
    img
  • “Loved this place! It was hopping; the food was delicious, and the service was excellent. It was a nice surprise.” Joanne
    img
  • “We grabbed a couple seats at the bar and had a great time. Ordered the seafood rice bowl with tuna and the Baja wrap—both were fresh, flavorful, and came out super fast. The bartender was really attentive and friendly, which made the whole experience even better. Overall, just a great spot. Definitely a must-visit if you’re in Sandy Hook.” Ralph Battista
    img
  • “What a perfect day to spend our lunch here. The food was great, and the service was phenomenal. They even allow dogs outside. Highly recommend coming here, especially after biking or hiking SandyHook beach.” Anne G
    img
→